top of page

The Current State of The Nanny Industry Amidst The Childcare Crisis

The ongoing childcare crisis is a well-known and widely discussed issue. Parents are continually trying to manage their childcare needs, and a number of nannies are actively seeking positions. The childcare cliff has significantly impacted the childcare and nanny industry. As a result, an increasing number of nannies are experiencing frustrations during their job search or when trying to switch jobs.

According to The Modern Nanny Census, 37.5% of nannies have been actively seeking a new position over the last six months. While 83% have successfully found their next job within a three-month period, 7% of nannies reported that it took them more than six months to secure the right position. These statistics shed light on the current state of the nanny industry and emphasize the challenges faced by childcare professionals, particularly in the wake of the pandemic.

This article aims to help nannies gain a comprehensive understanding of the industry and childcare in general, ultimately providing them with the necessary insights to efficiently navigate these challenging times. The focus isn't just on the difficulties, but also on the opportunities that exist within this evolving landscape. The goal is to empower nannies with the knowledge necessary to adapt and thrive in their chosen professional path.

Reports Are Out - Our least favorite major childcare monopoly,, has released their new Cost of Care report. As nannies and childcare professionals, we are all too aware that this report is grossly inaccurate. Unfortunately, many parenting and media outlets are using this data to promote misleading information. This not only misguides parents but also sets the tone that childcare will be a significant topic in this year's political election. It is crucial to question the sources and methods used to obtain such data. The Modern Nanny's current census serves as concrete evidence of just how flawed Care's data truly is.

The Childcare Cliff Has a Pandemic-Like Effect - Ever since the Childcare Cliff hit in September, we have been witnessing its adverse effects. This year, we are seeing an increase in pricing and closures of various daycares, whether they are in-home or center-based. In-Home Centers have been hit the hardest, with owners citing low profitability and burnout as the primary reasons for their drastic reductions. This has lead to more parents looking for a nanny especially if they are living in an area considered a “childcare desert”. We are desperate need of childcare funding and policy changes.

Not All Nanny Boards Are The Same - Childcare and Nanny Facebook groups, while not a new phenomenon, have surged in popularity. For families unable to affording working an agency, these boards serve as a reliable nanny-seeking platform. It is crucial to understand that each board operates distinctly. Some may lack stringent rules and oversight, leading to potential frustration. Conversely, some boards may suffer when the administration's ego interferes with the primary objective of enhancing childcare and the nanny industry.

Childcare Is a Hot Topic, and a Hot Scam - Unfortunately, scammers are taking advantage of the current situation to exploit both parents and nannies. We have come across instances of fake agencies and parents attempting to extract personal information from nannies or requesting money to complete tasks. Jovie and Bright Horizons have both been hit by phishing scams with people in Facebook groups claiming they are employees. Nannies and parents alike need to be on high alert and exercise caution. This sentiment also extends to big businesses. With the high demand for childcare, we are witnessing the emergence of numerous new companies aiming to strike it rich. However, some of these businesses are cutting corners or operating without proper legitimacy. It is crucial to thoroughly read the fine print and understand how your information will be used before engaging with any new platforms.

It's Slow Right Now - Typically, we observe an influx of job offerings during the holidays and the new year. However, this year has been slower than usual. Even agencies are experiencing a slowdown, with fewer customers coming in. Many agencies are starting to offer date night/sitter services to compensate for the lack of job opportunities. The next significant pickup in the job market is expected during Spring Break and the Summer season depending on the Summer Camp market.

Part-Time and Date Night Requests Are Up - Despite the overall slow market, there has been an uptick in part-time and date night requests from families. Parents are becoming smarter with their work hours and are carefully assessing their needs, even if it's just for a night out. Some nannies have found creative solutions by juggling multiple part-time families to make ends meet. Additionally, there are many stay-at-home parents who are looking for part-time childcare so they can care for themselves or run errands without the little ones in tow.

Cost of Care is Impacting Hours - Many families are finding themselves in a tight spot due to the high cost of living and childcare. As a result, parents are resorting to smarter work schedules or part-time care to optimize costs and family efficiency. This shift in dynamics has led to a reduction in full-time care requests and an increase in part-time care requests.

Working for an Agency Doesn't Guarantee a Job - It is essential for nannies to understand that working for an agency does not guarantee a job. Agencies can only present the clients they receive to nannies, but they have no control over the decision-making process. Ultimately, it is up to the parents to decide which candidate is the right fit for their family. Agencies act as intermediaries, providing pre-verified options to the families. Therefore, nannies should not be upset with agencies for not having a specific type of client or for not finding them a job fast enough. Ultimately, nannies should be looking for jobs on their own WHILE working with an agency.

Parents are Smarter - Many parents have learned valuable lessons from the pandemic and the unfortunate experiences of being scammed by untrustworthy nannies. They are becoming more vigilant and meticulous when it comes to vetting potential caregivers. Parents are now double-checking references and verifying experience to ensure they find the highest quality care for their children. Nanny moms, in particular, are facing the challenge of proving their previous experience to differentiate themselves from stay-at-home moms.

But Still Lack In Childcare Education - For every educated parent on childcare standards, there are at least five who are not knowledgeable. The most significant issue as a childcare coach is the lack of childcare education and understanding. This lack leads to frustrated parents and caregivers, resulting in burnout, inadequate compensation, and a lack of appreciation. To effect changes in the childcare industry, it is essential to educate parents about childcare before their child is born. This should include a discussion on childcare budgets and preferred options. It's about more than just finding a daycare or hiring a nanny.

SAHM Care is Being Pitted Against Nannies - The rise of companies like JuneCare has created a situation where stay-at-home moms (SAHMs) are inadvertently competing with nannies. These companies exploit the parent co-op loophole, resulting in a large number of SAHMs seeking childcare services provided at a lower rate by other mothers. This has caused tension within the industry, as there is a significant difference between general childcare experience as a parent and professional childcare experience as a nanny. SAHMs seeking nanny rates are driving up the prices, making it even more challenging for genuine nanny moms to enter the market and be valued.

Nanny Reality Check - In certain areas, nannies may be realistically pricing themselves out of their potential clientele. While it is not impossible to find a family willing to pay a high rate, it may take more time in the current state of the industry. There are fewer families offering top dollar and more families offering moderate to lower hourly wages. It is important for nannies to strike a balance and consider their current area and potential clientele to find a happy medium. Asking for $40 an hour in an area where families can afford a maximum of $25 will make it considerably more challenging to secure a job.

What Does the Childcare Industry Hope to See This Year?

Parents and childcare professionals are eagerly waiting for the current administration to pass some form of childcare funding. While a childcare tax extension has been approved, both policy changes AND tax rebates are necessary to jump-start the American economy. If the current administration fails to address this issue, childcare will undoubtedly become a hot topic in the upcoming presidential election. Parents and childcare providers are desperate for change, and funding is crucial not only to solve the childcare cliff but also to support the industry as a whole.

Furthermore, we anticipate the launch of numerous new companies claiming to have the solution to the childcare crisis. However, it is important to remember that no single company can single-handedly address this complex issue. It will require collaboration across various sectors to achieve greatness. When assessing these new companies, it is crucial to scrutinize their liabilities, terms and conditions, and program details to avoid falling victim to money grabs or the misuse of personal information.

Lastly, we need parents to educate themselves effectively. Despite the plethora of experts and resources available, many parents remain uninformed about childcare and their available options. Often, the information provided is fragmented or outdated. It is crucial for parents to "look at the source" and seek out accurate and up-to-date information. Guides such as Choosing Childcare 101 aim to provide comprehensive guidance to every parent.

In conclusion, the childcare and nanny industry is facing significant challenges in the current crisis. Nannies, parents, agencies, and policymakers must come together to find sustainable solutions and support the well-being of children and families. By staying informed, vigilant, and adaptable, we can navigate the current state of the industry and strive for positive change.


bottom of page